π Sound Library Research¶
Date: 2026-04-23
Purpose: Reference for sound library design decisions. Covers free soundscape sources, competitive category analysis, and clinical evidence for sound therapy approaches.
Part 1: Free Soundscape Sources¶
Recommended sources¶
| Source | License | Commercial app OK | Quality | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Freesound.org (CC0 filter) | CC0 | Yes β unrestricted | Up to 96kHz WAV | Primary field recording source |
| Free To Use Sounds | Proprietary royalty-free | Yes β explicitly permits app dev | 24-bit/96kHz WAV | Professional loop masters |
| Pixabay Audio | Pixabay License (permissive) | Yes β integrated use | 44.1kHz MP3 | Breadth, gap-filling |
| OpenGameArt (CC0 packs) | CC0 | Yes β unrestricted | 44.1kHz WAV | Curated ambient loops |
| numpy/scipy synthesis | None β generated code | Yes β no licence | Mathematically perfect | Noise colours |
How to use Freesound correctly: filter every search to CC0 only (license:cc0). The library contains CC-BY and CC-BY-NC tracks mixed in β the licence is per-sound, not per-library. Only CC0 is safe for commercial app embedding without attribution requirements.
Sources to avoid¶
| Source | Reason |
|---|---|
| BBC Sound Effects (Rewind) | RemArc licence β non-commercial only. PSE commercial licence available but not free. |
| Zapsplat (standard tier) | "Primary value" clause in standard licence is a legal risk for a sound therapy app where sounds are a core feature. |
| Meta AudioCraft / AudioGen | CC-BY-NC model licence prohibits commercial use without a Meta commercial licence. AudioGen outputs 16kHz β insufficient quality for a premium health app. |
| SoundBible | Outdated, uneven quality; licence varies per-sound and is unclear for many tracks. |
Noise colour synthesis¶
White, pink, brown, blue, and violet noise are generated programmatically β no sourcing needed. Python with numpy/scipy:
- White noise: flat power spectrum β
np.random.normal() - Pink noise (1/f): power decreases 3dB/octave β generated via spectral shaping in FFT domain
- Brown noise (1/fΒ²): power decreases 6dB/octave β integration of white noise
- Blue noise: power increases 3dB/octave β high-frequency emphasis
- Violet noise: power increases 6dB/octave β very bright, clinically relevant for high-frequency tinnitus masking
All exported as 44.1kHz 16-bit WAV, looped seamlessly (no crossfade artefact at loop point).
Part 2: Competitor Sound Category Analysis¶
Oto¶
UK tinnitus CBT app. NHS-adjacent, clinically validated (PMC 2025 feasibility study).
- 98 sounds in 10 categories
- Confirmed categories: Coloured noise, Urban, ASMR, Nature
- Differentiator: notch/boost mode on any sound (frequency cutout or boost at tinnitus pitch) β clinically meaningful
- Average user engagement with sound library: 14 minutes/session
Kalmeda¶
German DiGA (certified medical device, prescription-required, GKV-covered).
- Confirmed categories: Wind, Water, Forest, City/Urban
- Differentiator: marketed as "3D nature sounds" β spatially positioned audio. Only app that explicitly markets spatial audio as a feature.
- Spatial sound integrated into a 5-level structured CBT programme, not standalone.
ReSound Relief (GN ReSound)¶
Free app, clinical framing, no hearing aid required.
- Estimated 50β150 sounds in three categories: Environmental, Music, Therapeutic
- Confirmed sounds: frogs, birdsong, water, ocean waves, violet noise
- Differentiator: layer up to 5 sounds simultaneously with individual volume sliders and L/R balance. Most sophisticated mixing in the category.
- User-tags sounds by function: Soothing / Interesting / Background
Widex Zen¶
Widex (WS Audiology) standalone app, free.
- ~10β15 ambient nature sounds: sandy beach, rocky beach, birds by pond, forest wind, tropical night, summer rain
- Differentiator: Fractal tones β algorithm-generated chime-like tones that never repeat (mathematically infinite variation). Named by colour variant (Aqua, Lavender, etc.). The foundational Widex Zen patent family (US6816599B2 + DE/CA/EP/JP/AU, priority 2000-11-14) is now expired β so a non-Widex generative engine is buildable, subject to a freedom-to-operate review (see
fractal-generative-sound-therapy.md). Clinical evidence stays weak: the n=6 pilot (PMC6197965) plus two confounded n=20 studies, none isolating a fractal-tone benefit. - Fractal tones are marketed as addressing habituation β users supposedly cannot "tune out" a sound that never repeats. No study isolates non-repetition as the active ingredient; treat this as an unproven design rationale, not an evidence-backed claim.
AudioCardio¶
Stanford-validated. Fundamentally different approach.
- No soundscapes at all β uses inaudible/near-threshold tones at personalised frequencies (Threshold Sound Conditioning)
- Not comparable as a sound library product β different clinical paradigm
Beltone Tinnitus Calmer¶
- Essentially ReSound Relief with Beltone branding + tighter hearing aid integration
- Same layering engine (up to 5 sounds, L/R balance)
myNoise.net¶
Web-first (iOS/Android app available). Created by audiologist Dr. StΓ©phane Pigeon. Most technically sophisticated free tinnitus sound tool available.
- 200+ sound generators, including:
- Tinnitus Neuromodulator (partnership with Tinnitus Works)
- White Bursts Noise (patterned, time-varying)
- Peak Noise Generator (white/pink/brown/grey with frequency presets 60Hzβ8kHz)
- Notch Noise Generator (fully personalised spectral notch)
- Rain on tent, forest, ocean waves, japanese garden, tropical rainforest, thunderstorm, fireplace, birdsong, binaural beats, singing bowls, and 180+ more
- Differentiator: 10-band frequency slider on every generator. Allows precise spectral shaping around individual tinnitus frequency.
Generic apps baseline (Noisli, Relax Melodies, White Noise Lite)¶
Consumer apps establish baseline expectations: 20β50 sounds, nature + noise colours + ambient music, simple layering, no clinical framing.
Part 3: Clinical Evidence by Sound Category¶
| Approach | Evidence level | Key finding |
|---|---|---|
| Notched noise/music | Weak/modest β tonal tinnitus only | Largest double-blind RCT (Stein 2016, n=100) null on distress; 2 of 3 recent meta-analyses null; 1 barely significant (THI β8.6/3mo, Jiang 2025, n=793). Effective only for tonal tinnitus β€8 kHz, 1β2 h/day over months. Full dossier: research/notched-sound-therapy.md. |
| Fractal tones | Weak β n=6 pilot + 2 confounded n=20 studies | None isolates a fractal-tone benefit. Widex Zen patent family now expired (FTO review still needed). |
| Broadband noise (white/pink/brown) | Standard of care | Moderate evidence for loudness reduction and habituation support |
| Nature sounds | Indirect evidence | Promotes parasympathetic activation β stress reduction β indirect tinnitus benefit. ATA recommends dynamic, spatially varied sounds for retraining. |
| Spatial/3D audio | Emerging | ATA recommends spatially varied nature sounds for cortical retraining. Kalmeda markets this; no other consumer app. |
| Binaural beats / neuromodulation | Emerging | Not yet clinical standard |
Part 4: Recommended Sound Library for Naluma MVP¶
Based on the above research, this is the proposed category structure β spatial audio is the default for every sound in every category, not a separate tier.
| Category | Sounds (~6 each) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Water | Rain (light), Rain (heavy), River, Ocean waves, Waterfall, Lake shore | Most popular tinnitus masking category |
| Nature | Forest dawn, Wind through trees, Fire/crackling, Birdsong, Summer night, Tropical rain | Relaxation + attention diversion |
| Noise Colours | White, Pink, Brown, Blue, Violet | Synthesised β omnidirectional (no spatial position). Violet noise is a differentiator vs. most apps |
| Urban Calm | Coffee shop, Fan/ventilation, Train, Library, Light rain on window | Concentration use case; ASMR adjacent |
| Tone Therapy | Singing bowls, Gentle chimes, Soft drone, Tibetan bells, Crystal bowl | Sleep + relaxation; matches competitor category |
~30 sounds total. Noise colours are the only category without spatial positioning.
Post-MVP differentiator flagged¶
Notched noise/music is a possible personalization feature, not a flagship therapy. The clinical evidence is weak/modest (the largest double-blind RCT was null on distress; 2 of 3 recent meta-analyses are null), it works only for tonal tinnitus β€8 kHz, and it requires sustained daily listening over months β so it must be framed as wellness personalization ("tune a sound to your frequency"), never as a treatment claim. It is cheap to build (notch the synthesized noise via the existing FFT pipeline) and free-to-operate, and fills genuine whitespace (the canonical product Tinnitracks was discontinued in 2024). Recommended after the Phase-3 catalog, with an FTO + regulatory copy review first. Full evidence/product/IP analysis + recommendation: research/notched-sound-therapy.md.
Sources¶
- Freesound.org CC0 filter: https://freesound.org/search/?filter=license:cc0
- Free To Use Sounds: https://www.freetousesounds.com
- Pixabay Audio: https://pixabay.com/sound-effects/
- OpenGameArt CC0 nature packs: https://opengameart.org
- Meta AudioCraft licence: https://github.com/facebookresearch/audiocraft
- Oto feasibility study (PMC 2025): https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12575424/
- Widex Zen fractal tones clinical study: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6197965/
- Notched music meta-analysis (Jiang et al. 2025, 14 RCTs, n=793; THI β8.6/3mo, barely significant): https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39992369/ β NOTE: PMC8832119 (previously cited here as "the meta-analysis") is actually Huang et al. 2022, an uncontrolled n=29 study with null THI; corrected 2026-06-15. See research/notched-sound-therapy.md.
- ReSound Relief: https://www.resound.com/en-us/hearing-aids/apps/relief
- Widex Zen app: https://www.widex.com/en/tinnitus/relief/tinnitus-sound-therapy-widex-zen/
- myNoise.net: https://mynoise.net
- AudioCardio: https://audiocardio.com
- ATA Sound Therapy: https://www.ata.org/about-tinnitus/sound-therapy/
- Kalmeda: https://kalmeda.de